Published on:

The Intricacies of Love and Law in North Carolina: Navigating Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation Through Hull v. Brown

In the Tar Heel State, the unique legal doctrines of Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation are still very much alive and well. In simple terms, North Carolina lets you sue someone for messing with your marriage. It’s one of the few states that still do. So, if you’re having an affair or dating someone married, it may help to know the legal risks.

The Nitty-Gritty of Alienation of Affection

In legal terms, Alienation of Affection is when a spouse has the option to sue someone who they believe has intentionally lured away the affection of their significant other. To win this kind of lawsuit, the spouse who’s been wronged—they would be the plaintiff—must show that genuine love and affection once existed in the marriage. On top of that, they need to demonstrate that this love was significantly eroded because of the third party’s intentional actions.


Criminal Conversation: It’s Not What You Think

Don’t let the name mislead you; Criminal Conversation has nothing to do with criminal charges. It’s a civil action where the plaintiff seeks to prove that the third party engaged in sexual relations with their spouse. The kicker here is that you don’t need to demonstrate the third party destroyed the love in the marriage—the mere fact of the sexual involvement is enough for a legal claim.


Diving into Hull v. Brown

In the recent North Carolina case, Hull v. Brown, the plaintiff sued the defendant for Alienation of Affection, Criminal Conversation, and emotional distress. The defendant’s attempts to dismiss the case and transfer it to a three-judge panel were denied by the trial judge.


Next, the Court of Appeals weighed in, saying the trial court’s actions did not affect the defendant’s “substantial rights.” This meant that the appeal was premature, and the defendant would have to wait until all other matters in the case were sorted out before raising constitutional issues.


Takeaways from Hull v. Brown

  1. Interlocutory Appeals: The Court of Appeals made it clear that not every denial can be instantly appealed. In the Hull v. Brown case, the appeal was considered premature because it didn’t impact a significant right.
  2. Motion to Dismiss: The court’s refusal to dismiss the case shows that Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation are still actionable offenses in North Carolina.
  3. Civil Procedure Rule 42: The case wasn’t transferred to a three-judge panel, indicating that the lawsuit will proceed as it is, unless other unforeseen issues come into play.


Why You Should Be Alert

Engaging in an extramarital affair in North Carolina can open you up to more than just heartbreak—you could be looking at substantial financial penalties and an extended legal battle. These claims often show up during or after a divorce proceeding, adding fuel to an already fiery situation.


Final Thoughts

In North Carolina, matters of the heart can quickly become matters of the court. Unique lawsuits like Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation are still a part of the state’s legal fabric, as the Hull v. Brown case shows. So if you find yourself in a complicated romantic entanglement, consider speaking to a seasoned family law attorney to fully grasp the potential legal risks you’re facing. Here at Woodruff Family Law Group, we specialize in guiding you through the intricacies of North Carolina family law, providing you with strategic advice and robust representation. If you need a family law attorney, contact the Woodruff Family Law Group today to schedule a consultation.

Meta Title: Navigating Love and Law in North Carolina: Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation Explained
Meta Description: Learn how North Carolina’s unique family laws on Alienation of Affection and Criminal Conversation can impact your romantic life. Get insights from the Hull v. Brown case and understand the legal risks of extramarital affairs with advice from Woodruff Family Law Group.